Remember them? Do you have fond memories of wholesome adventures and happy mysteries? Well, you're wrong. Try reading them as an adult. I never read these books as a child and I have to say I was absolutely shocked by the sordid nature of some of the material. Allow me to share some quotes concerning the kindhearted yet misunderstood Grandpa Alden--"Now J.H. Alden liked boys. He liked to see them running and jumping and playing."
Ew.
Then the man said, "You see, I have lost a little boy, and I think the doctor knows where he is. My little boy is just about as old as you are."
"Well, if you don't find him, maybe you can have me," remarked Benny. "I like you."
"You do?" cried the man. "Come and get up in my lap."
Sonny, don't trust that man.
Beyond the ew factor there's the author's obvious lack of medical knowledge. Take Violet's instant illness. Here Jessie and Violet are laughing at Watch the dog's funny haircut that little Benny has given him--
Jessie laughed and laughed until she almost cried. Violet laughed until she did cry. Then she could not stop crying. She cried and cried. At last Jessie made up her mind that Violet was really sick.
"You must go to bed, Violet," she said. She helped her carefully into the boxcar and put pine needles all around her and under her. Then she wet a handkerchief in the cold water of the brook and laid it on her little sister's hot head.
"I wish Henry would come home!" said Jessie. "What shall we do?"
When Henry came home at last, he looked at Violet and said that maybe she had a cold. "Maybe she sat too long by the brook, " he said.
"If Violet is very sick, she ought to go to the hospital," said Jessie.
Uh-huh. So not only can sudden sickness come upon you from either a) laughing too hard or b) sitting by a brook, it can also lead to hospitalization.
Is this really the sort of material we want our young people to be reading? It could make them sick in more ways than one. They might grow up to be hypochondriacs who like to climb into stranger's laps, strangers who "like" boys. I'm going to propose that these books be banned from libraries altogether. And I'll be holding a book burning tonight if anyone would like to join me. Feel free to bring your Dick and Jane books too.



No comments:
Post a Comment