Friday, September 08, 2006

It Was A Good Day . . .

I was listening to Medusa. Ah, bliss. It's such a good album and I was happy to reunite with it. Once upon a time in the 90s (back when I actually purchased cds) I owned this Annie Lennox album. Then came the time when Ben and I had to . . . eat. Slowly, one by one, our cds were sold off. We literally had hundreds and eventually those were whittled down to about 5. Now I'm on a roll copying, copying, copying--I mean--borrowing cds from the library. My goal is to never buy a cd again. My apologies to the artists and their parasitic record companies.

Anyway, it was a good day. Listening to Medusa and then finding out that Mandy had started up another blog. Good day. It became a little less good (fun with grammar!) when I got my hopes up about attending the Daily Show at OSU and then had them crushed when Ben found out all the tickets were gone. But I recovered quickly.

Unfortunately, I talked to my husband that evening and that spoiled everything. I found out I'm not alone in what I've been feeling lately. See his side of the conversation here. My side of the story is the agnostic funk I've been in lately. I shouldn't really call it a funk because I don't feel depressed at all. Which brings me to a side point--Conscience is an illusion. If an agnostic funk was a horrible sin, you'd think I'd be depressed. C.S. Lewis points to conscience as proof that God exists, etc. I think conscience is purely social. If you've been taught that drinking coffee is evil, then you will feel guilty the first time you drink coffee. As far as I know God has not condemned coffee . . . yet. I really don't think anyone starts out with an unblemished conscience sent straight from heaven. Conscience is a result of education. Yes, there's the old Christian argument of "searing" one's conscience. Something bad no longer bothers you because you've done it so many times. That can be true. But who taught you it was bad in the first place? Is it your internal conscience speaking? Is it God? Is it your church, your mother, your guru?

During the last few years at our old church I was in a near constant state of conscience induced anxiety. My conscience was killing me with phantom sins. All sorts of neutral bits of life became revealing insights into my tainted soul. I tried to control everything, tried to be as perfect as possible because God and my church were out to get me. I was always afraid I was acting in a deceived state. I couldn't see what was really going on so I doubted all my motives. I thought I had a good heart but clearly I was deceived about that. I was evil to the core and needed to recognize that. I thought the anxiety was proof that I was sinning somewhere. If I could just squash that sin, I would be free and have a clean conscience that would eradicate my anxiety.

Then we left the church and within a few months all that anxiety was gone. God didn't seem so scary. Life didn't seem so cut and dry. I started to really believe in faith and a merciful God. I started to lighten up again, to de-evolve from my neurotically pious state. It felt good.

But then I found a weird consequence to being in a large church--dying people. When you're in a church of twenty people all under the age of 45, odds are no one's going to die. But when you're in a church of hundreds, you start to encounter stories of physical suffering. First it was Vicki and now Brandi. Young women of excellent character, shining witnesses for Christ being wiped out. Why would God want to take them? It doesn't make sense. That brings me to my main point--suffering and death and a good God don't make sense.

I know all the arguments--suffering is God's megaphone to a deaf world, we don't know the mind of God, everything happens for a reason, we live in a fallen world, etc., etc., etc. Right now I'm not in the mood to buy into any of them. They all seem a little false, mere philosophies we've created to ensure humanity doesn't make the collective leap off the bridge. Right now I can relate more to the nihilist point of view. Life and death are random. I don't think God doesn't exist, I'm just not sure God is interested in our opinions. Prayer really never accomplishes much because God has his own ideas. Or maybe it's not his idea at all. Maybe it's all cause and effect. I shouldn't be upset that people die early from cancer because it's just an effect from an earlier cause--messed up genes, a damaging sun, pollution . . . Shit happens.

I know the Bible has a lot to say about this. Trust God despite EVERYTHING around you. People suffering, evil people prospering, innocent people dying. And God does listen. Abraham and Moses talked God out of or into all sorts of things. "The prayer of a righteous man accomplishes much." Maybe I'm not righteous enough to negotiate with God. Maybe that's the problem. When Brandi relapsed I was ready. I thought, It's not over yet. I'll pray, I'll fast, I'll beg God to spare her. Then I got depressed. A lot of people were acting like this was it, it's over. What we really needed to do was pray for their emotional comfort during this time. I thought that lacked a little imagination to say the least. If God can do anything, why don't we pray that he'll spare her? But he didn't spare Vicki. Why should he spare Brandi?

One of our friends at church is a breast cancer survivor. The news about Brandi really messed with her. She didn't understand why she was spared and Brandi wasn't. She could have easily been in Brandi's shoes. Why did she get better and Brandi was getting worse?

Maybe because it's random.

I can really understand why people believe in fate now. I always thought people must be out of their mind to believe all things happen because they're meant to happen. But when you feel powerless, a fated system is almost comforting. I don't have to worry, I don't have to beg, because what happens happens. End of story.

I feel like I should just turn off my brain and have the faith I used to have regardless of my mood and what's happening around me. I love God. I think he's fantastic. I believe in a good God. The King and Creator of the universe who wants things to be better, who wants people to love and be at peace. It's this shitty stuff that happens that gets me. What's the deal? So as of now my philosophy is to praise God. I thank him all the time. I thank him for my children and the good things that happen, the beauty that's in this world and in so many people. But I don't blame him for all the evil. I don't get angry at him for suffering and sickness. And since he's not responsible for those things, I'm not sure he's responsible for fixing them either. So right now I'm not convinced that prayer is going to change them. We just need to roll with the punches.

I feel weirdly comforted in this state. But on an intellectual level I do see that it doesn't completely line up with the Bible. I know this isn't a place I'll be for the rest of my life, but for now it feels right.

No comments: