No, really.
I was expecting to see something that made me cry and feel compassionate towards all the gay cowboys of the world. I heard that in the theaters when the credits rolled you could hear the whole audience sniffling. I was ready to be sad. But, I was not and this is why--
There was no build-up. No significant glances, no gradual progression of relationship just BOOM! One minute you've finally progressed to having half a conversation and the next you're having gay sex. Surprise! That is when I learned my first Brokeback lesson--Sleeping in the same tent can make you gay. So if you're not interested, WATCH OUT when you go camping.
The whole movie seemed like it was all about the sex. It didn't do a good job of showing the relationship. You would think if you're going to carry this thing on for 20 some years, you'd really like each other. But they never showed that. It was mainly just sex and whiny arguments. Jake Gyllenhaal's Jack Twist was a WHINER. Whine, whine, whine. I need sex. Whine, whine, whine. Excuse my while I find a Mexican prostitute. At the end you see Heath Ledger's character with the shirts and the postcard and I felt kind of sad for his crummy life, etc. but it wasn't gut wrenching. I just didn't see the soul connection that was supposedly behind all this. And it was sickening what happened to Jack Twist but the movie didn't succeed in making me like him so I felt really distanced during that scene instead of devastated like I should have felt.
And I'm never a big fan of adultery no matter what gender it's done with. So that really decreased my sympathy for both of them. It is not nice to cheat on your wife no matter how much your kids cry or how irritating your in-laws are. And, while they butchered the gay relationship part, they did do a superb job in making married life seem absolutely wretched. And that's when I learned my second Brokeback lesson: Never marry a woman, it will only make you miserable. This is something I have no problem with personally but I know a lot of men out there will find it difficult to live with.
My favorite part of this whole Brokeback adventure was Ben's response at the end. "Men just aren't attractive. Women are attractive. Men aren't attractive." To which I replied, "So you think all of us heterosexual women are crazy. We should face up to the fact that men just aren't attractive? We should get rid of your gender altogether and just become lesbians and clone ourselves?" And he said, "I'm just saying I get the lesbian thing, but I do NOT get the gay male thing. I just don't get it."
I guess all I'm saying in this insightful and intelligent review is that it could have been done better. I was all prepared to be sympathetic, and I know a lot of the people who saw it were, but for me it just fell flat.
Oh, and Jake Gyllenhaal is ugly with a mustache. So there.



No comments:
Post a Comment