Wednesday, May 31, 2006

Why Can't People Just Be Perfect?

Is is too much to ask?

Laurel left a great comment on the MLK quote and I started to respond but it was becoming a post of its own. She said she was encouraged by Martin Luther King and the fact that he was so flawed and yet accomplished such amazing things. That just shows that we don't have to be perfect to be effective.

I was really struck by this because I have such a hard time balancing MLK's greatness with his weakness. I get swept up in what amazing things he did and just when I'm about to canonize him I remember how he cheated on his wife and I want to punch him. He had an incredible woman who was willing to stand by him even when people were bombing their house and threatening their lives and the lives of their children. I think I'd be a little less noble, a little more cranky and self-preserving. And he KNEW what a great wife he had but he still couldn't keep it in his pants when he was away. What the heck is that about!?!

These are the times I wish some people could be a little more perfect. I wish they'd leave a little less room for critics to pick them apart. Why didn't any of his friends pour some ice water down his pants? Everyone knew this was going on, why couldn't anyone just stand up and really be a friend, put him in his place and show him what an asshole he was being? (I'm sure some tried.) Most pastors would (and should) be removed from authority when they show themselves to be unrepentant adulterers. Maybe that was the problem. No one wanted him to be removed from authority. Maybe everyone just looked the other way because he was who he was. Who could replace him? Who could lead the movement like he could? But it's not fair.

Then I feel like I'm asking too much. I think, Look at what he did! How can you pick on someone who put his life on the line to free people from oppression? How can you pick on someone who wouldn't hate people who deserved to be hated? How can you pick on someone who refused to fight and kill just like Jesus refused? Could I do what he did? I have to be honest and say probably not. So why nit-pick?

Because adultery is a big deal!!! AAAAAARRRRRGGG! Adultery sucks! I think as a wife I know that most wives want a faithful husband. I think as a wife I know that a woman who is cheated on is not truly loved. It's so basic. Love=Faithfulness. It's not a difficult concept. Do people screw up? Yes. Should people be forgiven by their spouse after they've cheated? Yes, as difficult as it is, yes. But when it happens again, and again and again, it means they don't really want to stop. It means they don't want to do what it takes to remain faithful. It means they don't truly love their spouse.

I'm sure Martin Luther King, Jr. loved his wife a lot. And she obviously loved him. But that love wasn't complete on his end. It wasn't true. And that makes me so sad.

That's why Laurel's comment was so helpful. People are complex. People mess up and they mess up bad. No one is all good and very few people are all bad. We can't ignore the failings of great men any more than we can ignore their greatness. It is encouraging that God will use us even in our flawed state. The Bible is full of not so perfect heroes. Maybe that's why Saints are so problematic. We make someone a Saint and, in a way, that takes away their humanity. But when we take them as they were, flawed but great, we have a chance of really emulating them. Their achievements aren't in the special category of the sainted, they're in the category of the human.

No comments: