What makes it so ridiculous is that the young man with the sign is probably of the Brahmin caste. (He's light skinned too so that's even more in his favor.) And he's protesting the government raising the quota for OBCs going to med school. OBC stands for Other Backward Castes/Classes. Many of these upper caste students are going on a hunger strike. It's so nice to see the privileged protest. Poor things. The BBC had a med student on saying that India had equality, the caste system had been outlawed and now everyone needs to be judged by the same standards. What planet is she living on? (I might need extra funds to make sure that I can track her down specifically.) Having Brahmins tell the lower castes to make it on their own merit is like cutting off a person's legs and then telling them life is fair and they need to stand on their own two feet in this world.(Government and private doctors are also striking which is affecting several hospitals and disrupting normal care and emergency services. Charming.)
I must admit quotas always make me nervous. I hate the idea of admitting people based on anything other than merit. But what are you going to do when you have a society that prohibits people from getting the education and experience they need to get the proper merit in the first place. It seems like you have to start somewhere. And quotas do help those who normally would have been overlooked (even if qualified) get a crack at an education.
We have the same problem in this country. Whether people like it or not, many minority students don't have an equal shot at an education. It's not their fault. You can lay the blame everywhere but on an innocent kid. Is it the kid's fault they live in a bad neighborhood? Is it the kid's fault that our tax system basically guarantees that poorer kids get a less than equal education? Is it the kid's fault that his parents aren't supportive because they're either working 2 jobs to support their family or they're high or they were just never there in the first place? There are so many things stacked against poor kids that an educational quota system seems like the least we can do for the time being. It's too late and it's a band-aid, but it's something.
And back to India. What are the rules once these OBC are in med school? Don't they have to keep up with the same work load the upper castes do? If so--does India really have to fear the hospitals being flooded with doctors who don't know what they're doing. The upper caste would like for you to think that's exactly what will happen. But that just seems like the panic attack of the privileged when faced with what might eventually become the equal playing field they like to boast about.



No comments:
Post a Comment