Sunday, April 13, 2008

Reading . . . books

Okay, but first about reading the news. For years my news came solely through NPR, not the written word. So I think part of my brain atrophied and now I see newsy things in print and don't recognize them--like Mugabe. My brain sees that and says something like Muggabee. Thus, it's taken a lot of mental work to read about Zimbabwe lately. Or is it Zimmbubwee?

Now to that book thing. I recently finished the Amber Spyglass so I'm rid of Philip Pullman now--FOREVER. I'm definitely coming down on Ben K's side on this. What the heck?!? I found a few chapters interesting (I'm speaking total--all three books) and the rest was either Blah, Blah, Blah or downright annoying. He has a singular gift for undoing his own dramatic climaxes. He works the situations up to the point where things are exciting and there's tension and then BAM! let's it fall flat. Especially in the last book--the epic battle to save existence as we know it followed by a denouement so long and boring it almost brought me to tears. Self-sabotage. And in trying to be interesting and inventive, he really did skip all over the place and put in ghastly amounts of tedious and unnecessary details. Blah, blah, blah. I really wished I had just seen the movie. I think I might have thought it was a fun film and left it at that. Now I'm so sick of Lyra and Will and everybody else that I never want to hear them mentioned again let alone watch the movie. Ugh.

Now I'm reading Vanity Fair (the book not the magazine) and actually enjoying it. I typically don't like, you know, old stuff. (Please say that like a valley girl.) And I know that makes me seem like I have a double digit I.Q. and a personality with all the depth of a puddle BUT I don't care. I have modernist, post-modernist, whatever-modernist taste when it comes to literature. But I saw Vanity Fair the not so good movie with Reese Witherspoon and came away thinking that, although it was butchered on screen, I bet the book was pretty good. And it is. It's like Jane Austen but with a protagonist who's selfish and scheming and fabulously manipulative--so there's a lot less gooey sentimentality and romance. And it mocks just about everybody and that's refreshing, because something about empire waist dresses makes people take themselves far too seriously.
See?




And just for kicks, I'll end on this--




3 comments:

Mandy said...

okay, I agree. The third book totally dropped the ball. And there was never a more anticlimactic scene than the huge battle at the end. But I'll stick up for the first two books. I was riveted. Granted, I was also in sixth grade. But I still like them.

Me said...

You know, now that I think about it, book 2 wasn't too bad--definitely more readable and cohesive than the other two. In order from least bad to worst (how's that for phrasing?)--2, 1, 3.

And I do have to think that your age was a major factor somehow. Was it the fact that the main characters were close to your age and they were doing these remarkable things? What about it made it so gripping? I'm really curious about this so I'm going to expect an answer and will nag you until I get one. (Anne Marie, feel free to weigh in on this too since you feel so strongly about the books.)

Sam said...

I agree that the books aren't up to much. I first read them as they were coming out, and Philip Pullman was reading them at my local bookstore (because he lives in Oxford). But even though he was a local hero, I still couldn't convince myself that they were brilliant.