Tuesday, October 02, 2007

Okay, Okay

All I have to post about falls under the gripery section and I didn't want to drag people down, but you asked for it so here goes.

Church

*sigh*

Definitely experiencing major church disconnect.  You see, I have this naive little idea that a church is supposed to be good for something.  I have these completely bizarre and unrealistic visions of a church that really cares, I mean, really, really, actually, in reality CARES about the poor.  We happen to belong to a church that treats the issue of helping the poor like window dressing.  

The building campaign.  Excuse me while I retch.  We are about to embark upon a multi-million dollar building campaign under the catchy title of Building Bridges.  I think that's supposed to throw us off a bit--No, no, no, it's about building metaphorical bridges not buildings.  Now, as part of this campaign we are also doing some nice things like continuing to help a church in Costa Rica build their church and helping an orphanage etc. place in Zambia. They're also flirting with the idea of joining up with Habitat for Humanity and doing stuff locally with them (I predict this will never happen).  But these are such sidelines to the ultimate goal of having a big ass building to do big ass white suburbanite shit that will do very, very little in the way of actually changing lives.

The sad thing is, I think the leadership actually believes that they're doing really well in regards to the poor.  I think they really sit around slapping themselves on the back for the great work they're doing.  And what they're doing is great--there's just not enough of it.  I think they skipped learning about percentages in school.  

I know!  Let's do a story problem!

You have $100 dollars.  You send $1 to an orphan in Zambia and $1 to a church in Costa Rica. You spend $98 dollars on new shoes you don't really need.
Question:  How big of an asshole does that make you?

And most of the good things the church does do (the things I love about our church) are volunteer based.  In many cases, the church administration isn't sending money out, it's coordinating members of the church to spend their money and then sending out what's been purchased.  Don't get me wrong, coordination of resources is HUGE.  Without it nothing would get done.  I'd be thrilled if they did more coordinating.  People want to help, people want to do something good with their money.  Unfortunately, without direction most people just pop their cash into the offering thinking that the church is going to put that money to the best use possible.  Now THAT is naive.

Churches are like any other non-profit--you need to keep an eye on how much of your money is going back into the business itself, how much money is spent on advertising and drumming up more money vs. how much money is actually going to the people that need help.  Our church is under the delusion that a big, slick new building is going to change lives.  They wouldn't say that, but that's what they believe.  If you build it, they will come.  The problem is, they're not reaching the people they do have.  They're continually trying to get people to be involved, to join a small group or class, to volunteer.  A bigger building with more perks filled with even more people who feel even more anonymous isn't going to prompt people to get involved, it just won't.  And, God knows, those teachings aren't going to change anyone.  *snore*

And what's worse is that this decision is definitely from the top and only the top leadership. All our friends, even our friend who is a pastor in the church, (hm, come to think of it, she's in charge of all the helping poor people stuff--no wonder she's not into the building idea) are against it.  And these are the people who are really involved, these are the people who serve. So who is this building really for?  What needs is it really going to meet?  Because the people who really want to help others don't want it.

So on Saturday our pastor had a couple who work in Zambia stand up and talk about what's going on there.  They told a story about a woman who'd been widowed, sent away penniless by her dead husband's family and ultimately turned to prostitution in order to feed her children. Now she has AIDS.  The thing is, she knew she'd get AIDS eventually but she thought AIDS is a slow way to die and starvation is quick, so she sacrificed her own health and future for the immediate needs of her children.  She and her family are some of the people being helped by the center in Zambia.  There are 11 million people in Zambia and 1 million of those are orphans.  They also talked about a 20 year old man who's desperately trying to get work in order to earn enough money to finish his last two years of school.  Of course, since he has no education he's completely unskilled and any work he can do will only earn him enough to maybe survive--certainly not enough for school.  The Zambia center is now putting together a work training program.  These are good things, good things worth supporting.  These are the kinds of things that I would like my money to go to.  I want the resources I have to be spent on changing lives.

And our pastor just stood there nodding and smiling while these people told heartbreaking stories of need.  And when they were done he said, "Isn't that cool?"  I just don't know how you could hear a story about a woman wrestling with her conscience about becoming a prostitute to save the lives of her children and not be outraged.  Yes, it's good that the church will be instrumental in helping these people, but how can you then turn around and promote a huge building campaign that will probably spend as much on bathrooms and parking lots as on orphans?  Ben and I could probably pay for that man's yearly education expenses ourselves. Things in the third world are CHEAP and so much can be done with so little.  And here in the States so little can cost so much and the really meaningful things for the prosperous people are free (community, love, connection, spiritual guidance) and yet we insist on pouring our money into our suburban physical wants.

*sigh*

Thanks for prompting a post, Mandy.  

No comments: