Wednesday, September 19, 2007

Of all the things that matter in this world, this is not one of them

And yet it troubles me--how to rate a movie on Netflix.  

First of all, it's frustrating that there aren't half stars or quarter stars or even third stars.  A whole star is quite a commitment.  

And then there's the question of whether to rate the movie according to how much I liked it vs. how good it was.  I mean, can I really say that I "liked" Schindler's List?  Did I "enjoy" seeing the Holocaust on film?  Did it bring me pleasure to watch people shot and tortured?  No.  But I gave it five stars because it was a really excellent movie.  I thought 21 Grams was really well done but it was depressing as hell and not enjoyable in the least.  So we gave it 4 stars even though we technically didn't "like" it.  

But then there's the complete opposite situation when you know a movie is complete crap and you love it nonetheless.  I still have a soft spot in my heart for The Addams Family.  There's no justification, but I make no apologies.

And then there's the question of rating it as the person you are now or the person you were when you first saw the film.  I saw Sheena (you know, Queen of the Jungle Sheena) when I was a little kid (retrospectively, I think it was too little) and it revolutionized my youth.  I thought maybe I could communicate with animals too, maybe I too could be that special.  Sheena completely changed my trips to the zoo, let me tell you.  But I'm sure if I watched the movie now, it would only give me the B movie icks.  So how do I rate Sheena?  Because I must rate Sheena, yes, I must.  I decided to give Conan the Destroyer 4 stars because my sister and I loooooved that movie for all its campy greatness, and I'm pretty sure if I sat down today I would still laugh my head off.  I was disappointed that Netflix didn't have Beastmaster II though--classic film.  They only had the first one which sucked.  The sequel sucked too but in the hilarious way.  The dude carries ferrets around in a man purse for those times when only ferrets can save the day.  Classic.

Anyway, I feel like I'm sending Netflix all these mixed messages.  Perhaps this is why those red stars they put there to show how much they think we'll like a movie are always changing.  One day they think we'll love Snow Cake and a few days later they think we might almost like it maybe.  Poor Netflix.  

We loved Snow Cake by the way.  Loooooooved it.  Or at least I loved it.  I think Ben would have given it 4 stars.  AAAAAA!  That's another thing!  How can you really be expected to rate movies as a couple?  

Life is so hard.

1 comment:

Lauren said...

I disregard Joel's feelings about a movie and give it my own rating.