Thursday, August 02, 2007

And now that everyone's lost interest and I can no longer remember what I wanted to talk about

--here is my Deathly Hallows post.

First let me say that it took me so long to figure out what the heck was happening on the cover. When were they outside in some Druid structure, who are all those people in the background, what are those curtains, why is Voldemort falling, what the heck is Harry catching--the title of the book? Huh? Okay, so it's the final scene in the Great Hall (enchanted ceiling--duh) but I still don't get the curtains--so there.

Hmmm, big book.

Just wanted to pat myself on the back for calling the Snape and Lily thing, along with the Harry as a horcrux thing, along with Snape dying thing, along with Snape being totally good and basically the best thing ever thing, and the Malfoy's turning to the good side even though it was in the slightest way. Okay, I'm sure the rest of the world knew all that too but I gotta grab my chances to feel special where I can.

Disappointments:

--Ben and I wanted the prophecy to actually be about Neville. After everything that had happened it would have been great to have Neville kill Voldemort instead of Harry. But he did get to kill that damn snake.

--My emotional detachment. Too often books or movies try to have their cake and eat it too. They want the great death scene but they want the thrill and joy of having the characters resurrected too. So throughout the book, if a beloved character died, I didn't believe it at first. That really ruins the emotional impact, let me tell you. And ultimately she did pull that crap with both Hagrid and Harry. Harry's bit wasn't too bad though. She explained it pretty well and while I was a little disappointed he came back b/c I'd finally invested enough to feel grief and that was torn away from me, I forgave her. ("Will it hurt?" Ugh! Total tear fest.)

--Snape's death. Even though I knew it was going to happen, it was still horrible. Seriously depressed me. He was my favorite character. Kill Harry a hundred times over but save Snape! Alas.

--And Lupin and Tonks' deaths really pissed me off. First of all, I was angry that both of them came to fight when they had a kid at home. (Oh and about that--you're wizards for God's sake--don't you have some handy dandy birth control spell?!? Novices.) I know they needed all the help they could get but risking both parents was a jerk thing to do. Actually, I was a little angry at everyone's deaths. I really connect these books to the author so I don't just accept what happens, I think WHY did you have to write that? I know it would have been stupidly unrealistic (because if Harry Potter is anything, it's realistic) to have everyone escape unscathed, but still. I did see part of that interview Rowling did with Meredith (we're on a first name basis) and she explained that she wanted to have a mirror of what happened with Harry. She wanted a child to be cruelly orphaned to show just how evil Voldemort was. Fine, I forgive you . . . again.

--Bellatrix being killed by Mrs. Weasley. Rowling had done such a good job of making Bellatrix this formidable force of evil that having her offed by Molly Weasley just didn't do it for me. I know that was probably the point--evil BITCH (yes, I loved that part) anti-mother killed by the ultimate mother. But I still think McGonagall would have been a better choice. That witch can kick ass!

--Never finding out why Mrs. Norris is named Mrs. Norris. I thought for sure there was some story there. Bummer.

--Houses still being in place at Hogwarts in the end. Haven't we learned our lesson, people?!?

Huge gratifications:

--all the stuff I was right about! (Have I mentioned that I was actually right about something?)

--Snape's memories were quite nice. I was glad we finally got to see the sympathetic side of him. Finding out why Petunia was so upset by magic was nice too. Everyone's just so damn wounded and human! *sniff*

--All the Dumbledore insight was also very satisfying. I like the way she progressively made Dumbledore more human and flawed. It just makes him that much more lovable. Nitwit, oddment, blubber and tweak. *sniff again*


Anyhoo, I'm sure there's a lot more that I can no longer remember but that's the overly long gist of it.

Sad it's over.

4 comments:

Jennifer Elizabeth said...

I know this is probably everyone's reaction, but I totally agree with everything you said about book 7. Which is confusing to me, since we apparently differ so widely in our movie picks. I actually really liked The Prestige!

Lauren said...

Yea! I've been waiting for you to write the review that I was much too lazy to write.

Also, I felt that this book was written so much better than the others. I swear, if I ever have to read the words/phrases "mutinous," "said softly," or "a delicate shade of green" again I just might vomit. But she over-used adjectives and adverbs far less in this book than the previous ones.

She fleshed out Snape's story better than I could have imagined---the only length to which I predicted his vindication was that he would die in the process of saving Harry's life. Great effing backstory!

Have you read an article about Harry lacking any real moral struggle/development? It's really interesting...if you haven't read it I'll find the link.

You might still find out about Mrs Norris in the Encyclopedia.

Joel was really pissed about Lupin and Tonks, too. Somehow, I didn't end up caring as much. What's wrong with me?

And...that's all i can remember.

studmuffin said...

i finished the book last night and came back to your blog first thing. bravo making the calls you did.
for me:
how did neville get the sword from gridhook? no explanation there.
would have liked to see harry and ginny snogging. (i'm such a romantic...
did not like the nineteen year hence wrap up. too feel goody. out of character... and "albus severus"? how lame is that. has anyone ever heard of naming a child something new? lily, james, fred... why not billforth or chatterdam? much more english sounding and regal...
i had the same emotional bankruptcy when dumbledore died in the last book. no tears, couldn't believe he was deed. then the crazy train station at the end of the universe thing allowed me to be at peace with the passing of such a great character...
i need to go read the ending fight scene between v and harry one more time. short but sweet and very well crafted.
yeah, tonks was too cute to kick and lupin needed to stick around. that sucked.
but those brits are great at killing off main characters. the only exception being dr who, of course.
i still want to see more ginny/harry action. they were so dang cute!!!

Me said...

Ginny and Harry did snog, but that just wasn't enough for you, huh?

I think Neville got the sword from the sorting hat like Harry did in Chamber of Secrets. The sword was somehow connected to that hat--I dunno, it's all magic to me.

And I thought Albus Severus was the greatest thing ever and I totally choked up. Two great headmasters of Hogwarts, one Gryffindor, one Slytherin . . . weep! But overall I thought the naming thing was out of control--I was dizzy with all the Lily's and James's and whoevers. And that ending was way cheap--her writing style was suddenly simplified again and if she was going to fill us in on what happened to people, I would have liked to find out what people (esp. Harry) were doing for a living. We only find out about Neville. And they didn't tell us if Neville married Luna.

And am I one of the few people who actually believed that Dumbledore died? I didn't know so many people thought he was somehow going to come back. That was one of my few moments when I actually felt free to be really sad b/c I was so convinced he was gone, gone, gone. *sniff* It was nice to see him again at the train station at the end of the world.