Friday, July 27, 2007

Long and tedious Harry Potter discussion below that I can't imagine anyone but Mandy and maybe Lauren having enough patience to read

I'll start with the movie since everyone's probably seen that already anyway. So torn. There were some really great moments but it felt so rushed. They should just commit to having three hour movies. Trying to convert books like these into movies is so difficult, it makes every second precious. There's just no room for anything other than what happens in the book. So when they added all that extra Filch stuff and insisted on including Grawp even though that character could have easily been eliminated--Grrrrrrrr. It just made it so much more infuriating when they skimped on more important parts. Snape's worst memory was turned into a blip so that Hermione could have a weird CGI King Kong moment. Umbridge's observation of Hagrid's class was really funny in the book, so that totally could have added the humor rather than having Filch bust a boil on the camera. Ew.

I must admit, however, that I did enjoy the part where Sirius punches Malfoy. I know it wasn't in the book and it was just there for a cheap YEAH! moment, but I still fell for it. And while I was irritated at first that they made Cho the snitch, I can understand why they did it--no new character introduction and it ended the relationship with Harry promptly which is all they had time for. (Oh, and Harry kissing Cho--Ew. They looked like they were chewing each other . . . wetly.) The scenes in the ministry were pretty darn cool. I love how they made the Death Eaters apparate in smoky clouds. It looks sweet even if it makes Death Eaters seem much more capable than they were in the book. But I thought they made Bellatrix a little too deranged. And am I remembering correctly that Voldemort didn't try to kill Harry before Dumbledore got there? And then he just stood around chatting before he ran away from aurors. He was supposed to be driven away after trying to possess Harry--not by the threat of some sissy aurors.

Overall I just kept thinking, "I could have written a better screenplay than this!" Okay, I know I couldn't but I could have at least told the people who did to go back and do a better job.

(Side note: This movie reminded me once again that I am so not a big picture person. It was just like the baseball game--I would catch myself admiring some bit of scenery when I should have been looking at the action. I totally missed Umbridge slapping Harry because I was looking at the freaky kitties on the wall. When I read text books or instruction manuals I actually skip the bold print. I overlook it completely and it's not on purpose. Part of my mind must think that bold print is the obvious part, the part suckers fall for, and the real truth lies in the fine print. Unfortunately the rest of the world seems to think that putting things in bold makes them more noticeable. Stupid idea really.)

Random movie things of note:
--Draco Malfoy got really tall.
--I can't help but call Lucius Malfoy Luscious.
--Lupin's hair was tragic.
--And I was once again amused by Sirius's prison tattoos. Where'd he get the ink to do that while in solitary confinement? Did the dementors smuggle him ink in exchange for his cigarette ration?
--Dementors smoking is funny.


Now to the book!

Nah. I'm too exhausted now. I'll have to deal with the book later.

5 comments:

Lauren said...

I thought the movie was rushed, too, and choppy, and didn't flow well. Disappointed by that. There were a lot of things I thought were great, but I kept thinking (as with the rest of the movies,) if someone who hadn't read the book were watching, would they have any idea what was going on?

Right now I'm having a hard time remembering much about it at all, actually...ooh, but I did love the way the death eaters and the aurors flew around like smoky light, too. Very cool.

Me said...

I didn't realize the aurors flew around like that too. I was probably distracted by something non-essential, or I might have just been staring at Luscious.

Me said...

Ugh. I read over this post and found a million spelling typos. I have made the necessary corrections and apologize for any mental anguish this may have caused.

Lauren said...

Yeah, the aurors flew around in white smoke, but they also flew in bold print, so I can understand how you'd miss it.

The way I feel about typos is this: I only get irritated and snobby when ignorant people make them. if smart people who know the rules make them, it's creative license at best and carelessness at worst, so it's ok.

Please, please tell me you don't actually find Lucius to be Luscious?

Me said...

Lucius is absolutely luscious.