Thursday, March 22, 2007

Apparently I have lost my soul

because I didn't like this movie.

I read about it here and here. I heard numerous media whoevers say it was a fantastic film. I was primed.

But then . . . meh. MEH?!? How can this be? This movie had everything I love in a film. It was a movie about a repressed individual discovering life and love with a heavy dose of the surreal. Emma frickin' Thompson was in it! (I must confess I once owned an Emma Thompson/Kenneth Branagh biography and pored over it like a new found gospel.) This movie had Will Ferrell! Dustin Hoffman! Queen Latifah! (It is so nice to see a beeeeeeeautiful woman on screen who is not size 4 or less.) Ben would say, "It had Maggie Gyllenhaal in it!" But I would not. (She's another person who plays the exact same character in every movie. Or maybe I'm just not familiar enough with her work?)

Anyway, I just don't get it. I should have liked this movie. I should have loooooooved this movie. But I didn't. It felt like it was 5 hours long. The surreal wasn't surreal enough. I felt like it just didn't blend--there was the surreal and the real and they just weren't connected enough. I'm not making myself clear at all.

Ben loved it. This movie is now one of his favorites. This, combined with my confusion over my own dislike, became very alienating. Then he had to watch all of the special features and interviews and of course all those people thought the script was fabulous and the movie came out great and blah, blah, blah. And I found myself in the very difficult position of disagreeing with my beloved Emma Thompson. It hurt.

I'm not saying there weren't some great moments. Emma Thompson was so nice to watch. The ending monologue was quite nice. And I really liked everyone's workplaces and apartments--I've never seen so much cool architecture and decorating in a movie.

But I would never want to see this movie again.

Ever.

4 comments:

Mandy said...

Yeah, I'm not Maggie Gyllenhall's number one fan either. But every other person in that movie I loved.

What sucks about you not loving it is how much you *wanted* to love it. Maybe it was hyped too much for you? Hype *ruins* movies for me, and I'd actually heard a lot of people say, "meh," which lowered my expectations beforehand, and left me pleasantly surprised.

Lauren said...

Ditto to the 'hype--' I really, really try not to expect much from movies anymore. (or life in general. pretty sad, really.) I'd read some reviews where people talked about how this movie had all the right elements but still fell flat somehow. The only person who loved it was my sister Megan, and the trustworthiness of her reviews is sketchy. So I was a little surprised to find myself loving it. Also surprised to *not* love Queen Latifah, on whom I occasionally crush and in general think she's a pretty solid actress. Her performance was a bit thin, here, I think---could it have been a wee bit ambitious to put her opposite Thompson? Anyway. I don't think you've lost your soul, Jaime, and I don't know why, exactly, but I think I understand why some people who perhaps should like this movie just won't.

studmuffin said...

i agree... it was the hype.

same thing for me and gigli.


anyway, i truly am sorry that you did not like the film, i had such high hopes for you... we'll miss you in heaven.

actually, give it a few years before you say never. i said that about sisterhood of the traveling... i mean, er...
anyway, you might come back to it some random october evening when she, the progeny and i are over for spaghetti and you will truly enjoy it... or else!!

not that we'll be over in october or anything, but you have to keep your options open...




...was the heaven crack over the top? (and ben, don't tell jaime, but i also thought that one highlight was maggie... who cares about character developm-- i mean, great personality, that one...)

Jennifer Elizabeth said...

Jaime, I am in complete agreement--it wasn't what it should have been. My main issue was that the book itself didn't seem to be great. What is great/unique about a boring man falling in love with a woman who is completely different from him, and having a few dates? What ELSE made the book so fantastic that we didn't get to see?