I didn't get enough of her in Children of Men so I was glad to see that The Prize Winner of Defiance, Ohio was in our mailbox Saturday. Woo-hoo!I'd heard about the book on NPR (*sound of angels singing*) when they did an interview with her daughter a while ago but had no idea there was a movie until I read about it on Jennie's blog. I think we must have seen a different movie though, because I had a completely different reaction.
I thought it was lovely. I actually cried and it's been a while since a movie made me do that. If even half the things that happened in the movie were true and if she was even half as wonderful in real life, I think she should definitely be beatified. She had a husband who spent the grocery money on booze when he had 10 kids to feed. (Thank you, thank you, Lord, for birth control and not being born a devout Catholic!) He left it up to her to hold things together with money from prizes she won and then felt insecure about his status as provider. Um--duh? You're not a good provider--that's probably why you feel guilty and insecure. Then he would get angry at her for "being too damn happy" and for staying home with the kids and "doing nothing" all day but writing entries for contests. Huh? I didn't come away thinking she'd been cold to her husband at all--I was amazed how often she coaxed him back into feeling like one of the family when she had every right to let him have it. There were a lot of times she ignored him when he was in one of his fits, but she did that to keep her and the family from being dragged down by his violence and anger.
On a tangent--it reminds me a little of how my mom taught us to handle my grandmother. My grandmother has this uncanny ability to hurt people with her comments and verbal jabs. Previously my mom would address this head on but it only ever resulted in intensifying the situation even more. Eventually she saw that my grandmother was never going to change--no matter how often she tried to reason with her. So to spare us the pain she'd gone through as a child, my mom chose to make light of it. Before we'd go over to her place my mom would say, "Let's see how many times Grandma is mean this visit." And it became a joke. I never once have felt hurt by my grandmother even though she's said some really bitch things and seems at times to live and breathe manipulation. And it was because my mom chose to distance us from it. I can love my grandmother because she never gets under my skin. I saw that in this movie too. When the father was behaving horribly the mother would just carry on cheerfully and work around him rather than take him head on. She knew he wasn't going to change so she decided to be the change her family needed.
It was almost bizarre how she could remain so positive and even cheerful when things went wrong every time she turned around--especially when you think about what their life would have been like if her husband had been more responsible with money. She could have had trips and a fancy car and all sorts of extras that were all sold just to keep them afloat. Talk about shaping your own reality. Her daughter's memoir could have easily been a story about complete family dysfunction but her mother made it a story of triumph.
You'd just have to see it. Like I said, if even half of it is true, she was an amazing, amazing woman--definitely someone for Moira to add to her photo montage. I'm going to watch the movie with the kids tonight.



4 comments:
I was quite impressed with the movie too. The husband was a jerk, but he was portrayed rather sympathetically. They told what drove him to his alcoholism, he was a pretty nice guy when he wasn't drunk. He just lacked all ability to think of anyone other than himself.
We saw a trailer for this forever ago, and I forgot all about it----thanks for the reminder! To the top of the queue it goes.
My fave Julianne Moore movies are, I think, The Hours and The End of the Affair. Seen either one and/or have thoughts on them?
Hmm--I have not but I can queue them! I'm so giddy with this Netflix thing. I'm getting really spoiled.
Netflix could possibly be the best thing to ever happen to me. I have been known to be driven to violent outbursts as a result of video store visits, where I never find anything good anyway.
The Hours: brilliant but depressing adaptation of the brilliant but depressing novel of the same name which I first read during a brilliant but depressed time in my life. I almost want to tell you to read the book first just so you can be amazed at how well it translated into film....but it's not strictly necessary.
The End of the Affair: Adaptation of a Graham Greene novel. Yes, it involves an extramarital affair and yes, our girl does show her boobs, but it's not nearly as tawdry as it might sound. Lovely and disturbing themes of hate and love and faith.
Post a Comment