Sunday, August 20, 2006

1 Timothy Part 1

I want to be honest when dealing with the Bible. I want to do what God wants me to do even if I don't understand it. So . . . what do we do with passages in the Bible that we don't like, passages we might even find offensive?

Right now at church we're going through 1 Timothy. 1 Timothy has a few verses that aren't that compatible with our modern sensibilities. Chapter 2 verses 9-15 for example--

Likewise, I want women to adorn themselves with proper clothing, modestly and discreetly, not with braided hair and gold or pearls or costly garments, but rather by means of good works, as is proper for women making a claim to godliness. A woman must quietly receive instruction with entire submissiveness. But I do not allow a woman to teach or exercise authority over a man, but to remain quiet. For it was Adam who was first created, and then Eve. And it was not Adam who was deceived, but the woman being deceived, fell into transgression. But women will be preserved through the bearing of children if they continue in faith and love and sanctity with self-restraint.

Hm.

Our pastor, in my opinion, took the coward's way out and didn't deal at all with the second part of these verses. He found it controversial enough to deal with modesty--male and female. Modesty I can deal with. I have a real problem with the way women are viewed in this society. Why is it the women who have to be dressed immodestly in the movies while the men can keep their clothes on and still be sexy? I think many women view their immodesty as a sort of power, power they can exert over men. But I think the joke's on them--they're objects whether they like it or not. Not that I agree with the whole burka thing (despite my wistful longing for one of my own). I think if a woman's wrists or hair sends a man into a sexual frenzy then that's the man's problem. Maybe he should just wear blinders and carry a cup of ice water to dump down his pants in case of emergency. Why should the women be demonized? (Although it is a little flattering to be considered just too damn sexy to walk down the street without a sheet thrown over you.)

I think these 1 Timothy verses do a bit of demonizing themselves. I know these verses have been used to keep women quiet. I know these verses have been used to make women out to be dangerously deceived. Don't listen to a woman because of Eve. Idiot Eve. This reasoning doesn't make sense to me at all. "And she gave also to her husband who was with her and he ate." Many, including the Jews, take this to mean that Adam was present during Eve's temptation. The loser just stood there and watched. Eve was operating on misinformation and she was ultimately deceived. Fine. But why does that make Adam better? He had the correct information and he blew it too. Eve was deceived and this is why women should shut up and be led by men who have as their ancestor an out of it husband who set his wife up for failure and then blamed her for it. If Adam wasn't deceived then he willfully rebelled against God. Isn't that worse? Isn't a person who was tricked more innocent than a person who sins in full knowledge of what they're doing? And does this supposed one time event justify the subjugation of women throughout history?

Because of the Adam and Eve reference I'm not completely comfortable with just dismissing these verses as "cultural." The author is giving a definite biblical reason for this attitude towards women. I don't think it's honest to pick and choose what's cultural. I think if you want to allow women to be pastors, to be equals with their husbands then you should also be willing to dismiss attitudes toward homosexuality as cultural.

Despite the tone of this post (kinda uppity ain't it) I am willing to do what this verse says. I've lived that way before and I can do it again. What's funny is that Ben has more of a problem with these verses than I do. He recognizes that a husband and wife, and men and women in general, need each other. We need the other to pull us back from the brink when we're going the wrong way. Men and women both have leanings that aren't healthy and we need each other to point them out.

It's interesting that the story of Adam and Eve and how Eve was created demonstrates equality. She was made from Adam's rib to show that she stands beside him. She wasn't taken from his foot so she could be stepped on. That's why I find these verses so curious.

Any thoughts?

No comments: