Pictures like these still horrify me. Maybe it's the fact that I'm a mother now or maybe I'm just getting older and more empathetic, but violence, particularly against innocents, literally makes me sick. Besides crying and cursing I now get seriously sick to my stomach over a lot that goes on in this world.And as many of you know I have a serious bent towards vengeance. Ben calls it my Empress Complex. I start to preach about what I think should happen (it usually involves imprisonment and/or smacking) and Ben asks me what else Empress Jaime would like. Well let me tell you, I've thought about it. People in the news media should be smacked. Unfortunately, the horrible stories they get their jollies out of sharing are actually true in most cases. Psychotic people kidnapping and torturing and killing people, parents abusing kids, bombers, sex offenders. . . Well, you name it and I have got the punishment for it. I've seriously spent way too much time trying to think out what the best death penalty would be for the worst offenders. It involves a tank of water, a hungry shark, a slowly retracting diving board and the dark.
I'm thinking about all of this because Zacharias Moussaoui got the AOK to face the death penalty today. After verdicts were read he reportedly yelled "You'll never get my blood, God curse you all!" Throughout his trial Moussaoui has repeatedly proven that he ain't none too smart. Somebody should have told him that cursing the jury is not the best way to win friends and influence people.
And, maybe he deserves the death penalty. The question is should we give in to that all too human temptation to exact vengeance? I think if we really care about what Jesus said, the answer is no. No matter how much I want to see my shark fantasy in action, deep down I know that we shouldn't put people to death. There are so many victims out there just aching with pain and anguish and so many of us think that in order to show the victim respect we need to kill the monster that caused that pain. An eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth. But how can we claim God's on our side?
Ben and I watched this documentary about the death penalty (I'm totally blanking on the name right now) and it was truly shocking. (Just thinking about the possibility--and now we know, the reality--of accidentally executing the wrong person should make America want to do away with the death penalty today.) It was so sad and so completely understandable to see these families who had suffered so much saying that they wanted someone to die. Seeing the people who had committed these monstrous acts and hearing them say what they had done to another human being made me think of nothing but vengeance. I just couldn't help but think, these people don't deserve to live one more day. But the most amazing thing about the documentary was a group of victims and victim's families that had formed to protest the death penalty. It was heartbreaking. They had a scene where the individuals in the group stood up one by one and told the horrifying thing that had happened to their loved one and then said, "And I am against the death penalty." It was beautiful in the way that only forgiveness can be.
I think Christianity is a religion of second chances, and that, unlike human beings, God is able to swallow the pain and forgive anything and anyone. And I believe that our perfect God can feel pain infinitely more acutely than we can. So for Him to forgive people like Paul who stood in the cheerleading section while Stephen got his skull crushed and was responsible for many Christian deaths is saying a lot. Christians often make God out to be either blood-thirsty and vengeance obsessed or some forgiving Santa in the sky who never takes anything too hard. "Shucks, Johnny, I know you raped and murdered your neighbor, but ya' know, everybody's got faults. No hard feelin's, okay?" Let's give God some credit. He anguishes over what happens more than we ever could and yet He wants reconciliation for every single person, murderer and victim alike. He wishes for none to perish. And you can't accuse God of disrespecting the victim. Forgiveness is an agonizing task and Jesus was begging God to forgive even while he hung on the cross.
I think everyone deserves another chance simply because they are human beings. Look at what happened in Paul's life. What if he had gotten what he deserved, when he deserved it? And what about David? He had a man killed. It was premeditated murder to save his own skin. What did he deserve? What about Moses? What about Cain? God didn't enforce the death penalty for any of these murderers. Even Cain. This is the God that said "your brother's blood cries out to Me from the ground." He knew about injustice, He was on the side of the victim, but He didn't take Cain's life. And maybe Cain isn't the poster child for redemption, but look at the others I mentioned. Look at Tookie Williams. Certainly not a patriarch, but he was a man who repented. He changed because he had time to change. And what could he have accomplished if given more time? We'll never know because he got what we as humans decided he deserved.
Of course, the Bible is complex. The Old Testament especially is full of incongruities that don't match up with what Jesus said. You can't dismiss the times when God allows for what amounts to ethnic cleansing or when He has the earth swallow people up or calls for people to be stoned. But neither can you dismiss the times in the Old Testament when God talks about longing for His people to return to Him and when He forgives over and over and over again. Clearly that is the part we should imitate. Vengeance is His, not ours. We should leave death in God's hands. It's definitely safer that way.
So, yes, I believe everyone can be redeemed and because of that everyone should be given the length of their lives to repent. Do I think every murderous psycho should receive their second chance out of jail and on the streets? Nooooooo. But I don't think we should be the ones to whack 'em either.



2 comments:
i feel exactly the same way. i've received alot of flack for it, but i can't deny this gut conviction. it's just the road that i know, deep down, i should choose to take. the other option feels too human, too faulty. thanks for having the courage to post it... it's something i've eluded to, but never actually come out with (in the blog world, that is.)
I really appreciate this post. I just wrote something similar, I even used the same picture. It's surprising to me how easily we have learned to baptize hate and revenge into the way of Jesus. Thanks again for writing this.
Post a Comment